Project-Based Learning (PBL): Learning in Action! 6 : Problem-Based Learning for Real-World Solutions

 Project-Based Learning (PBL): Learning in Action! 6

Problem-Based Learning for Real-World Solutions

Who doesn’t enjoy detective and spy stories? Recently, I read a book detailing secret operations by British intelligence MI during the Second World War. While reading the storybook, I came across an captive narration about an operation titled Operation Chastise.

Operation Chastise, famously known as the ‘Dam Busters Raid,’ was a daring mission carried out by the Royal Air Force (RAF) during World War II on the night of May 16-17, 1943. The goal was to disrupt industrial production in Germany's Ruhr Valley by targeting Möhne, Eder, and Sorpe dams. These dams which were playing a crucial role in hydroelectric power and water supply for Germany.

Led by Wing Commander Guy Gibson, a specially formed RAF squadron, the 617 Squadron, used Barnes Wallis's innovative ‘bouncing bomb’ designed to skip over water and breach the dam walls.

The squadron faced significant challenges due to the unique nature of the mission. Flying at low altitudes, under enemy fire and searchlights, they successfully breached the Möhne and Eder dams, causing catastrophic flooding downstream and disrupting industrial production in the Ruhr Valley.

Although the Sorpe Dam sustained only minor damage, Operation Chastise was considered a significant success for the Allies. The mission showcased innovative tactics and bravery but came at a cost, with eight of the nineteen Lancaster bombers lost and many crew members perishing in the operation.

 After reading thrilling account of attack on the dams I searched for information about how they prepared for the attack.  And I came across fascination account of work on a real problem-solving project. 

During WW 2, a group of engineers and planners was assigned a challenge to create a disrupt in Germany's industrial heartland.  To achieve their goal to cause disruption Germany's industrial heartland they come up with idea targeting dams in the Ruhr Valley. The mission was titled as Operation Chastise.

In a secret facility placed away from prying eyes, a team of engineers meticulously crafted scaled-down replicas of the Möhne, Eder, and Sorpe dams. These models were not just ordinary miniatures; they were detailed works of art and engineering, carefully designed not only to mirror the structures, dimensions, and landscapes but the strength of the actual dams.  

Creating these models wasn't a task accomplished solely by imagination. The engineers needed accurate data, and then the daring aerial survey team was invited to join the project. Brave pilots soared through the skies in specialized aircraft equipped with high-resolution cameras and sensors. Their mission: to capture every detail of the targeted dams and their surroundings. Flying over enemy territory, they snapped photographs.

Then a teams of geographers, engineers, intelligence and meticulous analysts pored over the photographs and measurements obtained from risky survey missions. Every photograph revealed vital information - the dams' dimensions, spillway locations, potential weak points, and the surrounding terrains. With help of critical information acquired scaled-down replicas were constructed. Every curve, every detail, and every feature were replicated with utmost accuracy. Then the team constructed scaled-down models of the targes replicating all structural material and strength details to analyze structural strength and vulnerability of the dams to plan an effective attack. They studied the dam's construction materials, weak points, and how the water would react upon breaching.

Parallelly a team from weaponry under Barnes Wallis developed the bouncing bombs those which can glide on water and the wall. On these models of dams, the testing of bouncing bombs was carried out. To mimic the specific conditions of the raid, they conducted extensive experiments. team realized that a cylindrical bomb, spinning backward, could skip over the water surface like a skipping stone when released at precise speeds and altitudes. 

The bomb team conducted numerous tests with scale models in water tanks to perfect the bouncing bomb's design and bouncing mechanism. These tests aimed to ensure the bomb would skip over the water, hit the dam at the correct angle, and detonate at the optimal depth to cause maximum damage. Based on the impact on models’ modifications of team refined the bouncing bomb's design and its impact.  

Then Dam Busters Raid was carried out by the Royal Air Force (RAF) on the night of May 16-17, 1943.

Combined and joint efforts of

Identifying problem by Planning and defence team

Defining impact point of action by Strategic analyst

Data collection by survey team,

 Survey Data Analysis and interpretation by analysts,

detailed dam models by model makers.

 innovative bouncing bomb design by innovation team and

 meticulous testing by investigation team

The multidisciplinary efforts, including problem identification, data collection, analysis, model construction, innovative design, and rigorous testing played a crucial role in the success of the raid on the Ruhr Valley dams during Operation Chastise.

The collaborative, multidisciplinary approach in addressing real-world challenges, from problem identification to rigorous testing and innovation within Operation Chastise, exemplify the essence of project-based learning.

The problem-based approach within project-based learning not only encourages the acquisition of skills, methods, and processes such as collection, surveying, and investigation, but also offers opportunities to integrate these processes at an application level while working on problems.

Problem-based learning provides context for investigation and collaboration.

Problem-based learning involves various phases of problem-solving that contribute to a comprehensive educational experience. It initiates by listing a range of issues prevalent in our surroundings - Identifying Problems -Collection of Information and Data Processing - Thinking of Alternative Solutions - Selecting a Solution and Testing It - Achieving Impact.

The ultimate goal of Problem-based learning is to find solutions that benefit society. Even minor problems can have a significant impact when addressed effectively.  

PBL equips students with the skills and mindset needed to devise innovative, practical solutions to real-world problems.

During a recent visit to an innovation fair, I encountered a fascinating project that highlighted the power of problem-based learning. A young boy from a village had discovered an issue while harvesting crops using the same sickle for different plants. Recognizing the varying needs and efforts required for cutting distinct plants, he embarked on a project to redesign sickles. Initially, he engaged with local farmers, understanding their challenges and needs. Subsequently, he worked on multiple sickle designs, testing them on various crops to ensure their efficiency. After several iterations, he developed a design allowing adjustments within a single sickle, a demonstration to problem-based learning.

The essence of problem-based projects lies in identifying the issue at hand as a problem and subsequently brainstorming innovative solutions. If you visit https://nif.org.in/IGNITE , you will discover how students from diverse backgrounds across India generate innovative ideas to address the problems around them.

We frequently use the term 'Learning by Doing,' which emphasizes physically engaging in activities to acquire knowledge.

However, during problem-based projects, students get the opportunity for 'Learning while Doing,' emphasizing the simultaneous process of learning and applying knowledge during ongoing tasks or experiences. This approach promotes hands-on experience, active problem-solving, and the integration of knowledge into practical scenarios, fostering a deeper understanding and skill development within real-life contexts.

Both approaches advocate experiential learning but differ in their emphasis on integration of learning within the activity. Problem-based projects are important for learning while doing as they engage individuals in real-world problem-solving.

Problem-based projects are crucial in education as they foster critical thinking, practical application of knowledge, and real-world problem-solving skills, empower students to actively engage with real-world issues, promoting a deeper understanding of society.

Prashant Divekar

Jnana Prabodhini, Pune

To read earlier articles

Project-Based Learning (PBL): Learning in Action! click

Postswith label Project based Learning (PBL)